[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / agatha2 / animu / arepa / fascist / general / mde / qsourcex / vichan ]

/animu/ - Anime & Otaku Culture

take it easy!
Email
Comment *
File
Password (Randomized for file and post deletion; you may also set your own.)
* = required field[▶ Show post options & limits]
Confused? See the FAQ.
Embed
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Oekaki
Show oekaki applet
(replaces files and can be used instead)
Options

Allowed file types:jpg, jpeg, gif, png, webm, mp4, swf, pdf
Max filesize is 16 MB.
Max image dimensions are 15000 x 15000.
You may upload 5 per post.


Rules / Useful links / Board log / QTDDTOT
Friends: /bane/ /cute/ /cyoa/ /japan/ /loli/ /monster/ /sticker/ /u/ /vg/ [combined]

File: 90ebb5e61e42e7b⋯.jpg (388.21 KB, 1920x1080, 16:9, 656714.jpg)

 No.60730

Why does it seem like Genos is more of the protagonist than Saitama is?

 No.60735

saitama can't be a protag because he is a static character (he's as strong in ep 1 as he is in ep 12 both physically and emotionally)

genos on the other hand can grow so he ends up feeling more mc-ish


 No.60737

File: dc78ab079286f6d⋯.png (894.91 KB, 776x828, 194:207, dc78ab079286f6da3cef65cb6f….png)

>>60730

Saitama doesn't really show agency or goals he really works for. He says he wants to just be a hero for a hire and he is so he's kinda "made it"; we're all just waiting for what next hijinks is going to make him stop his heroing career or look like a bad guy. Too bad the manga has been too focused on power levels and hero ranking bullshit instead of hijinks. He kinda doesn't care about other people and most of the major fights happen because shit comes to him in comedic fashion instead of him going out to pre-emtively. Genos has an origin story a reason to travel out in the world and a reason to find other people to help him get stronger. His fights show how powerful the world is around him and how small he really is in the univers when, on the otherhand saitama could probably fight everyone in the universe, win, and not even know what happen. Genos does appreciate the connections to the characters he's met more than Saitama and doesn't seem to have an apathetic stance with every single encounter with every character. Also you want to see more of genos as he is a cool looking robot, too bad he is a jobber. Genos is early shounen protagonist before the story goes full retard.

The House of Evolution arc and the fight between Saitama and Tatsumaki have the best parts in my opinion that really capture the spirit of the manga. Garo fight is the coolest part though.


 No.60758

>>60730

Haven't you ever watched a comedy before? The show is named after the comic character (eg, Sherlock Holmes) while the audience is supposed to connect the most with the straight man (eg, John Watson).


 No.60759

Because he effectively is. He's the setup to the joke, the more traditional fighting series character who's almost ready to say things like "I'd follow you to hell!" or "but he still has *that*!", and Saitama is the punchline where none of that matters and expectations are flipped.


 No.60935

>>60730

Neither of them are. Saitama is the manga's punchline, while Genos is the setup that keeps pushing the story forward. Character development is a factor but they don't seem to be evolving much.


 No.61029

because you can actually root for Genos.

When Saitama enters a fight, you know it ends as a joke.

With Genos, you never know. Will he job? Will he put up a decent fight? Will he actually kick ass?

There is much more emotional investment in him than Saitama. Genos still has his revenge quest, that somehow got forgotten, but drives him forward.

Saitama does what he does out of boredom.


 No.61214

>>60735

Not sure how you can say that when Geno's acomplishments dont seem to get any better after every upgrade. If anything we see some new flashy shit he does but still gets his ass handed too, so he his flashyness goes up but his accomplishments still remain stagnated.


 No.61217

>>60730

It's not that Saitama can't be a protagonist, because he's all about the dullness of absolute power. The problem is that One has barely anything to say about this, other than some shallow Superman comparisons.

Saitama has basically been reduced to nothing in the remake manga, whose filler essentially turned into pre-sjw Marvel, as the series focuses solely on the other heroes. He was left behind for the muh animashun bucks.


 No.61222

>>61217

>The problem is that One has barely anything to say about this, other than some shallow Superman comparisons

Maybe that's why I never seemed to get into OPM. It's an intriguing concept, but I don't know where one could go with it. What would be the best way to use Saitama?


 No.61227

>>61222

>this one guy can solve any problem but he's just one guy vs a world of problems

>politics of being a hero (how do you decide who to save, who decides how heroes are dispatched to best serve the community)

>other people taking credit for your accomplishments

>power envy

all of these were addressed in s1 of the anime


 No.61228

>>61227

>power envy

I meant that as both to the fellow heroes and to villains; while he might be the strongest guy on earth would he also be the strongest in the universe? does his existence draw villainous attention from across the universe?


 No.61232

File: 441ed7d41e0a255⋯.gif (601.39 KB, 307x500, 307:500, 441ed7d41e0a25578b1b543e5b….gif)

when was the last chapter? I feel like there has been a massive delay, or at least it feels like it over the last 2 being pretty boring. Where is Garou? I want Garou.


 No.61239

>>61228

>does his existence draw villainous attention from across the universe?

That's literally the most boring this you could ever fucking do with the concept.That's just "And then he keeps punching bigger and more powerful enemies" you idiot.


 No.61245

>>61239

>draw larger enemies

>humans decide they don't want you as a beacon for destruction

>send you off into space

>now earth is unprotected


 No.61246

>>61228

Pretty sure it has something to do with God and he probably has interest in Saitama. There were almost no monsters before he became a hero. Now the world is falling apart because of monsters and they get even stronger and stronger. Beings such a Boros and Garou start appearing. We know that God gives powers and power in general seems to come from some source seeing as there is a way to farm it.


 No.61252

>>61245

You seem to have mistaken this series as being a genuine action superhero story and not the character study of superheroes that it actually is.


 No.61253

>>61252

>entire show is about humans deciding whether they want to accept the risk of having you around

>hero of course has the opportunity to tell everyone to fuck off

>not a study in the character of humans/heroes


 No.61311

File: d227f01e4447e86⋯.png (93.94 KB, 794x204, 397:102, 025-1.png)

Well, it started as a gag manga that people want to be to the new dbz. Saitama himself is an analysis of what makes someone a hero. Saitama would be the first to say that being strong doesnt make you a hero, but a hero should push themselves to be strong. In many ways Saitama is the immutable man. He doesn't change, but the world has to change around him. That's why Genos is juxtaposed against him - in a story told straight Genos would be the perfect edgy underdog hero, and in many ways since Genos is genuinely heroic he can recognize the depth of Saitama that is often overlooked. Genos wants to grasp what Saiatama has, so he follows him. Saitama mighy now grow, but through the story we can pull back his layers, and see how he effects growth amongst his peers.

Another thing One likes to do, as seen in Mob Psycho, is investigate human social relations, especially between being genuine and simple minded, or complex but insincere, and what are your limits to your virtues. One likes simple protagonists with depth. Of course, Mob grows as he establishes his convictions, while Saitama just asserts his own, but they both have trouble "fitting in." Anywho, I'd like to avoid rambling much longer.

tl;dr

>>60730

I think the point is to come off that way, to tell the story better, since that's what most of the characters in the manga themselves think.


 No.61350

>>61253

>hero of course has the opportunity to tell everyone to fuck off

He literally did that in fucking episode 4, you colossal dumbass.


 No.61494

>>61222

>What would be the best way to use Saitama?

The farcical commentary on organized communities seemed to point toward the idea that Saitama was a real hero, in a world oversaturated with fakes. He could have been hidden in plain sight, performing feats that the rest of the community claimed for themselves.

You can see elements of this with King and Licenseless Rider, but again it's just brief citations and gags. There's no big discourse involved, other than 3-4 speeches by Saitama in the entire series (a big problem in the remake, is that it shifted focus from this sparse discourse, to acshun). But to be frank, capeshit isn't exactly big on the gray matter.


 No.61498

If Saitama was a woman and wanted to rape you how fucked would you be?


 No.61503

>>61498

zero

cause I would be raped


 No.61513

>>61498

The equivalent of being fucked by a female Saitama. duh


 No.61542

>>61498

Doubt you would be even able to penetrate her. Her vag flaps would be like squeezing your dick past steel but more like immovable.




[Return][Go to top][Catalog][Nerve Center][Cancer][Post a Reply]
Delete Post [ ]
[]
[ / / / / / / / / / / / / / ] [ dir / agatha2 / animu / arepa / fascist / general / mde / qsourcex / vichan ]